I love New York, and there is literally nothing better than grabbing a New York Slice when visiting the city. But with so many options, it can be hard to find where the best pizza joints are. While there are hundreds to visit, one of the best slices I have had was at The Pie Guy. Here is everything you need to know.

The Pie Guy Pizza

Their funny saying is, ” The only guy you should call late at night. Come get a slice,” and I can’t help but agree with that.

When we randomly stumbled upon the pizza shop after visiting Chinatown’s Ice Cream Shop, Soft Swerve, they had a variety of slices. They were just a few blocks away!

The Pizza

Grabbing a slice was easy, and they had plenty to choose from. But I have to try a classic slice when judging a new pizza joint in NYC. I can tell pretty quickly if they are legit or not.

Their Classic Slice was legit, with whole milk mozzarella and homemade tomato-basil sauce. The sauce was everything a NY slice should be, with robust flavor.

The Menu At The Pie Guy Pizza

If you want to try other slices besides a classic, you can! They have Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Buffalo Chicken, and so many more.

They have an extensive menu of Italian favorites. Try the Spicy Rigatoni, made with a homemade vodka sauce and finished with Calabrian chili, fresh mozzarella, and baked rigatoni.

Late Night Delivery

Don’t want to leave your hotel room but want to try The Pie Guy Pizza? You’re in luck! They are popular for their late-night delivery options. From Thursday through Saturday, they deliver until 3:00 AM!

Where Is The Pie Guy Pizza?

They are located near Chinatown and Lower Manhattan.

After you are done chowing down at The Pie Guy Pizza, make your way over to this cannoli hot spot: Little Italy Is Home To This Famous Cannoli.

Then visit NYC’s Chinatown Ice Cream Shop: Soft Swerve!

Looking for a good drink spot in NYC? Check out this hidden speakeasy in Midtown.

New York City Collection