Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

If you’re visiting Bar Harbor, Maine, chances are you’re here for Acadia National Park, fresh lobster, and stunning coastal views. But if you’re a true foodie, there’s one quirky treat you must try—Lobster Ice Cream!

Where to Find Lobster Ice Cream in Bar Harbor

We stumbled upon Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium, a popular candy shop and ice cream parlor in downtown Bar Harbor, while exploring the area.

When we saw Lobster Ice Cream on the menu, we knew we had to try it.

Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium

Ben & Bill’s has been serving homemade ice cream in Bar Harbor since 1983.

While they offer classic flavors like Maine Wild Blueberry and Maple Walnut, their most famous—and most daring—flavor is Lobster Ice Cream.

What Does Lobster Ice Cream Taste Like?

I know what you’re thinking: “Seafood and ice cream? That can’t be good!” But trust me, it’s surprisingly delicious.

Here’s what you can expect from this Maine specialty:

• Creamy vanilla base
• Chunks of real lobster meat
• Buttery, slightly salty flavor
• No fishy taste!

It’s a perfect blend of sweet and savory, with the fresh lobster pieces adding a slight chew.

It may sound weird, but if you’re a foodie looking for one of the most unique treats in Maine, it’s worth a try!

If you want an actual lobster roll, make sure to check out my recommendations. 21 Best Lobster Rolls in Maine: From A Local! (2025)

How Did Lobster Ice Cream Start?

Rumor has it that Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium created the unique dessert in the 1980s to prove that their ice cream was homemade.

Whatever the reason, it quickly became one of Bar Harbor’s most famous foodie experiences.

Other Must-Try Flavors at Ben & Bill’s

If you’re not quite ready to dive into Lobster Ice Cream, try some of their other Maine-inspired flavors:

• Maine Wild Blueberry Ice Cream – A classic, made with real Maine blueberries.
• Maple Walnut Ice Cream – Sweet Maine maple syrup with crunchy walnuts.
• Moose Tracks – A rich chocolate-peanut butter swirl.

Should You Try Lobster Ice Cream?

Absolutely! If you’re visiting Bar Harbor, Maine, and love adventurous eats, Lobster Ice Cream is a must-try.

It’s a fun, unique, and surprisingly tasty treat that perfectly captures the flavors of Maine.

You will have plenty of tempting options when you go up to the Ice Cream counter. But do yourself a favor and do not leave until you try this Lobster Ice Cream in Bar Harbor.

Would you try it, or is this too daring for your taste? Let me know in the comments!

Explore More of Acadia

If you love trying new foods, here are some other must-visit foodie spots near Acadia!

Want more lobster rolls? Head over to Abel’s Lobster: The Best Lobster Roll Near Acadia!

Make sure to Treat Yourself To A Popover At Jordan Pond House!

Looking for a place to stay near Acadia? 13 Great Places To Stay Near Acadia National Park

Read all of my Maine Travel Guides!