Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
It hit nearly 70 degrees this past weekend in New England, so we packed up for a spontaneous coastal road trip down the coast of Maine. After spending the day wandering around, I suddenly got a craving for my first lobster roll of the season. I was beyond excited to see a lobster roll shack I have not tried yet, The Buoy Shack.
The Buoy Shack in Maine
Located on Badgers Island in Kittery, Maine, The Buoy Shack sits right on the edge of the Piscataqua River. It offers stunning views of downtown Portsmouth just across the water.
This open-air lobster shack is a perfect New England spot, which shows a working waterfront with the laid-back vibe of a summer getaway.
Tropical Drinks By The Water
It was the perfect day to enjoy a freshly made tropical cocktail while overlooking the water! So we ordered up a round.
We tried the Rum Punch and Dark & Stormy, which were perfect island drinks. They also offer a build-your-own margarita, which I was tempted to try. Next time I will!
The Buoy Shack Lobster Rolls
The Buoy Shack is known for its fresh Maine lobster rolls, packed with locally caught knuckle and claw meat from York, Maine.
Served on a toasted brioche bun, you can choose between a light lemon mayo dressing or warm drawn butter.
I was feeling the lobster roll with mayo today, since it was finally nice and hot out. It was paired with freshly made coleslaw, which was equally as tasty.
This lobster roll was sooooo good. The lobster was fresh and delicious, and the roll was perfectly crispy and buttery. It was literally such a treat for an April day in May.
It was so good that it earned a spot on my Local’s Guide to the Best Lobster Rolls in Maine 2025!
We also tried the “Catch of the Day” fish sandwich. This locally caught white fish is lightly breaded (gluten-free) and fried.
It was crispy and flavorful, served on a brioche or gluten-free bun with tartar sauce and greens!
More Lobster Rolls in Maine
I have made it my mission to eat every lobster roll in Maine and some of them have become my favorites.
Here are my picks for the Best Lobster Rolls in Maine 2025!
Want a unique lobster treat? Try Lobster Ice Cream! This Bar Harbor Chocolate Makes It Work!
Read all of my Maine Travel Guides for hiking trails and hidden gems.
Want to eat your way through New England? Read all my New England Travel Guides!
Heading to Portsmouth? Make sure to read my Portsmouth Foodie Guide: Best Eats on a Self-Guided Food Tour!
Where Do You Want To Travel Next?